Tests & reviews

Edelrid - HMS Bulletproof Triple FG Eco - HMS carabiner tested

Reviews overview

Our reviews are 100% genuine. More info

What do you think about that?

You have reached the max. number of characters.

Oops! You forgot to ask your question.

Click the number of stars to complete your review of this product

Click the number of stars to complete your review of this product

What is your review for this product?
(Click stars for your review mark)
Upload image

By completing this upload you confirm our Terms of Use

This is what customers from around the world say:

Faus
12.07.2022

  • Advantages
    Quick to open
    Price / performance
    Finish
    Excellent handling
Carsten
16.07.2022

25% have found the reviews
by Carsten helpful

Product images by Carsten
  • Advantages
    Finish
Joelle
29.06.2025

  • Advantages
    Excellent handling
  • Disadvantages
    Difficult to open
Evie
10.03.2025
Depends what you're using it on

Doesn't work with the grigri+ as it seems to grab on the steel insert in cross-loading situations, and the carabiner just seems to catch on the grigri+ a lot. Also doesn't work with the megajul as the carabiner is too thick for that scenario too.

The gate unlocking action may be good or bad in your use case -- you MUST push up before twisting, as twisting while pushing up requires more force while pushing up. Maybe that's just an issue with the eco though.

The ACL is very strong though. Much better than the carabiner it was intended to replace -- an austrialpine ronda

Ended up just going on my PAS instead

  • Disadvantages
    Difficult to open
Melanie
15.01.2025

  • Advantages
    Excellent handling
    Finish
Marlo
15.01.2024

  • Advantages
    Excellent handling
    Wide coverage
    Finish
    Quick to open
Stefanie
15.08.2023

  • Advantages
    Quick to open
    Finish
    Excellent handling
    Price / performance