Tests & reviews

Stoic - Merino260 StadjanSt. Jacket - Merino jacket tested

Praise vs. Criticism

James

14.06.2024

Comfortable.

I am 181 cm tall, 102 cm chest 82 cm waist and my arm “Ape index” is 6 cm longer.
I bought size M, and it fits perfect, it's especially good on the arm length as it has thumbholes, and it does not stretch the arm material with my long arms.
The top is stretchy, which is great for movement.
The fit is excellent for my body type, and I can wear a base layer underneath it and an outer layer over it without it feeling bulky.
The only downside is it pills easily both on the inside and the outside, and It's starting to lose its shape, but that is the general trade-off you make between wool and synthetic fabric. The quality of the stitching and attention to detail is exceptional.

Advantages
Good details
Good cut
Disadvantages
Pills easily
VS

Prentiss

12.05.2025

Is this even really wool?

I bought this to replace a beloved wool-blend jacket from another manufacturer but I was very disappointed. The Stoic doesn't look, feel, or smell like merino wool. It performs like an ordinary synthetic/cotton jacket, not wool. It makes me wonder whether there was really a sheep anywhere in the picture.

Oh, and the zipper is terrible. Avoid.

Disadvantages
Bad zip
No discernible wool

What do you think about that?

You have reached the max. number of characters.

Oops! You forgot to ask your question.

Click the number of stars to complete your review of this product

Click the number of stars to complete your review of this product

What is your review for this product?
(Click stars for your review mark)
Upload image

By completing this upload you confirm our Terms of Use

This is what other customers say:

James
14.06.2024

50% have found the reviews
by James helpful

Comfortable.

I am 181 cm tall, 102 cm chest 82 cm waist and my arm “Ape index” is 6 cm longer.
I bought size M, and it fits perfect, it's especially good on the arm length as it has thumbholes, and it does not stretch the arm material with my long arms.
The top is stretchy, which is great for movement.
The fit is excellent for my body type, and I can wear a base layer underneath it and an outer layer over it without it feeling bulky.
The only downside is it pills easily both on the inside and the outside, and It's starting to lose its shape, but that is the general trade-off you make between wool and synthetic fabric. The quality of the stitching and attention to detail is exceptional.

  • Advantages
    Good details
    Good cut
  • Disadvantages
    Pills easily

Oops! You forgot about your comment

Prentiss
12.05.2025
Is this even really wool?

I bought this to replace a beloved wool-blend jacket from another manufacturer but I was very disappointed. The Stoic doesn't look, feel, or smell like merino wool. It performs like an ordinary synthetic/cotton jacket, not wool. It makes me wonder whether there was really a sheep anywhere in the picture.

Oh, and the zipper is terrible. Avoid.

  • Disadvantages
    Bad zip
    No discernible wool

Oops! You forgot about your comment

Question from Martin
20.11.2023
Size

Hi, does this run small, tight or just regular?

Oops! You forgot about your answer

Adrian (Community) | Customer Service
21.11.2023 08:47

Hi Martin,

The fit here is very much regular.

This is what customers from around the world say:
Stefan
26.11.2023

100% have found the reviews
by Stefan helpful

The thread was edited on 26.11.23

  • Advantages
    Breathable
    Good details
    Good cut
    Lightweight
  • Disadvantages
    Pills easily
Thekla
06.06.2024

42% have found the reviews
by Thekla helpful

  • Advantages
    Breathable
    Good details
    Price / performance
    Good cut
Armin
10.05.2024

  • Advantages
    Breathable
    Good cut
    Price / performance
  • Disadvantages
    Pills easily
Severine
13.03.2023

100% have found the reviews
by Severine helpful

  • Advantages
    Price / performance
    Breathable
    Good cut
    Lightweight
  • Disadvantages
    Pills easily
Susanne
16.12.2022

  • Advantages
    Price / performance
    Good cut
Andreas
09.12.2022

66% have found the reviews
by Andreas helpful

Stan
18.12.2023

Taghi
14.02.2023

60% have found the reviews
by Taghi helpful

  • Advantages
    Lightweight
    Good cut
    Good details
    Breathable
Christophe
19.03.2023

33% have found the reviews
by Christophe helpful

The thread was edited on 19.03.23

  • Advantages
    Good cut
    Price / performance
    Lightweight
Andreas
26.01.2024

  • Advantages
    Good cut
    Lightweight
    Price / performance
Axel
14.12.2021

42% have found the reviews
by Axel helpful

  • Advantages
    Lightweight
Nadine Mörschel
02.10.2025

  • Advantages
    Price / performance
    Lightweight
    Good cut
    Breathable
Andrea
15.09.2025

33% have found the reviews
by Andrea helpful

  • Advantages
    Good details
    Good cut
    Price / performance
    Lightweight
    Breathable
Sascha
11.09.2025

  • Advantages
    Good cut
    Lightweight
    Breathable
Karlheinz
21.08.2025

  • Advantages
    Breathable
    Lightweight
    Price / performance
    Good cut
Michael
26.07.2025

  • Advantages
    Good cut
    Price / performance
Michaela
11.05.2025

  • Advantages
    Lightweight
    Good cut
    Good details
Ralf
03.05.2025

  • Advantages
    Price / performance
    Good cut
    Breathable
    Lightweight
  • Disadvantages
    Pills easily
Bart
26.03.2025

  • Advantages
    Venting
    Good details
    Good cut
    Price / performance
    Breathable
Daniela
15.03.2025

  • Advantages
    Good cut
    Breathable
Armgard
30.11.2024

  • Advantages
    Robust
    Lightweight
    Breathable
Michael
21.11.2024

  • Advantages
    Price / performance
    Good details
    Lightweight
    Good cut
    Breathable

There are 121 more threads!